|
Year |
Name |
Hometown |
Local Title |
| 2010 | Becky Minger | Sylvania | Miss All-American City |
| 2009 | Erica Gelhaus | St. Henry | Miss Clayland |
| 2008 | Karissa Martin | Woodsfield | Miss Clayland |
| 2007 | Roberta Camp | Grove City | Miss Maple City |
| 2006 | Melanie Murphy | Brook Park | Miss Miami Valley |
| 2005 | Marlia Fontaine | Massillon | Miss Lake Erie |
| 2004 | Amanda Beagle | Warren | Miss Lake Erie |
| 2003 | Janelle Couts | Akron | Miss Medina |
| 2002 | Tiffany Haas | Cincinnati | Miss Heart of it All |
| 2001 | Natalie Witwer | Dublin | Miss Ashland |
| 2000 | Stephanie Meisberger | Hopewell | Miss North Coast |
| 1999 | Tiffany Baumann | Cleveland | Miss Greater Cleveland |
| 1998 | Cheya Watkins | Cincinnati | Miss Southeastern Ohio |
| 1997 | Kelly Creager | Hamler | Miss Conneaut |
| 1996 | Robyn Hancock | Grand Rapids | Miss Crestline |
| 1995 | Ellen Pasturzak | Portsmouth | Miss Portsmouth |
| 1994 | Lea Mack****** | Pickerington | Miss Pickerington-America |
| 1993 | Titilayo Adedokun*** | Cincinnati | Miss Americana |
| 1992 | Robin Meade****** | Wakeman | Miss Mansfield |
| 1991 | Renee Autherson | Newark | Miss Central Ohio |
| 1990 | Kristi Cooke | Marion | Miss Willard |
| 1989 | Kristin Huffman***** | Canal Winchester | Miss Pickerington-America |
| 1988 | Sarah Ann Evans | Van Wert | Miss Pickerington-America |
| 1987 | Susan Kay Johnson | Columbus | Miss Canton |
| 1986 | Mary Zilba | Toledo | Miss Greater Toledo |
| 1985 | Suellen Cochran****** | Heath | Miss Southeastern |
| 1984 | Melissa Bradley** | Mansfield | Miss Clayland |
| 1983 | Pamela Rigas***** | Canfield | Miss Cuyahoga Co. Fair |
| 1982 | Debra Gombert | Bexley | Miss North Central |
| 1981 | Juliana Zilba | Mansfield | Miss North Central |
| 1980 | Kathy Vernon****** | Youngstown | Miss North Central |
| 1979 | Tana Carli** | Lakewood | Miss Willard |
| 1978 | Sher Patrick**** | Centerville | Miss South Central |
| 1977 | Joan Gilger | Mansfield | Miss Bowling Green |
| Susan Perkins* | Middletown | Miss Clayland | |
| 1976 | Janice Cooley | Portsmouth | Miss Ohio Valley |
| 1975 | Susan Banks**** | Ravenna | Miss Warren |
| 1974 | Lorrie Kapsta | Columbus | Miss Franklin County |
| 1973 | Cheryl Youkvitch | Lorain | Miss Lorain |
| 1972 | Karen Sparka | Bowling Green | Miss Bowling Green |
| 1971 | Judy Jones | Miss Miami University | |
| Laurie Lea Schaefer* | Bexley | Miss Bexley | |
| 1970 | Grace Bird | Alliance | Miss Alliance |
| 1969 | Katherine Baumann** | Bowling Green | Miss Bowling Green |
| 1968 | Leslyn Hiple | Louisville | Miss Canton |
| 1967 | Pamela Robinson | Dayton | Miss Dayton |
| 1966 | Sharon Phillian**** | Delaware | Miss Delaware |
| 1965 | Valerie Lavin | Canton | Miss Canton |
| 1964 | Diane Courtwright | Columbus | Miss Columbus |
| 1963 | Peggy Emerson | Akron | Miss Akron |
| 1962 | Bonne Gawronski | Miss Toledo | |
| Jacquelyn Mayer* | Sandusky | Miss Vacationland | |
| 1961 | Darlene Depasquale | Dayton | Miss Dayton |
| 1960 | Alice McClain | Marion | Miss Marion |
| 1959 | Carole Weiler | Circleville | Miss Circleville |
| 1958 | Margaret Putman | Ada | Miss Ada |
| 1957 | Linda Hattman | Mansfield | Miss Mansfield |
| 1956 | Roberta Palmer | Cleveland | Miss Cleveland |
| 1955 | Marguerite Garr | Cincinnati | Miss Cincinnati |
| 1954 | Barbara Quinlin****** | Alliance | Miss Alliance |
| 1953 | Martha Zimmerman | Salem | Miss Salem |
| 1952 | Carol Koontz | Bolivar | Miss Bolivar |
| 1951 | Ruth Howell | Apple Creek | Miss Apple Creek |
| 1950 | Irene Farren | Grand River | Miss Grand River |
| 1949 | Florence Bondi | Cleveland | Miss Cleveland |
| 1948 | Maxine Waack | Fairview | Miss Fairview |
| 1947 | Nancy Nesbitt | Cleveland | Miss Cleveland |
| 1946 | LaVonne Bond****** | Cincinnati | |
| Mary Eileen Kelly | Cleveland | ||
| 1945 | Julia Donahue | Oxford | |
| Virginia Lee Pleasant | Cincinnati | ||
| 1944 | Madeline Bohanon | Cincinnati | |
| 1943 | Joan Hyldoft | Cincinnati | |
| 1942 | Barbara Patterson | Cincinnati | |
| 1941 | Janice Sulzman****** | Willoughby | |
| Lois Jean Beck | Cleveland | ||
| 1940 | Violet Berze | Steubenville | |
| Bette Jane Hart | |||
| 1939 | Jeanne Saboda | Cleveland | |
| Maxine Drumm | |||
| 1938 | Marilyn Meseke* | Marion | Miss Marion |
| Evelyn Bertelsbeck****** | Cleveland | ||
| 1937 | Jean Fadden****** | Cleveland | |
| Evelyn Townley****** | |||
| Sally Lillian Frank | Cincinnati | ||
| 1936 | Evelyn Townley****** | ||
| Dorothy A. Duncan | Cincinnati | ||
| 1935 | Beatrice Pfeiffer | Cincinnati | |
| Eleanore Papin | Cleveland | ||
| 1933 | Corinne Porter****** | ||
| 1927 | Evelyn Wilgus | Russells Point | |
| 1925 | Elarka Towne | Conneaut | |
| 1924 | No Miss Ohio | ||
| 1923 | Mary Katherine Campbell* | Columbus | |
| 1922 | Mary Katherine Campbell* | Columbus |
*Miss America
**1st Runner Up
***2nd Runner Up
****3rd Runner Up
*****4th Runner Up
******Semi-finalist