YearNameHometownLocal Title

2024


2023


2022

Stephanie Finoti (4)


Madison Miller


Elizabetta Nies

Columbus


Coshocton


Cincinnati

Miss Shawnee


Miss North Coast


Miss Maple City

2021Lora CurrentDegraffMiss South Central Ohio
2019
2020
Caroline Grace WilliamsCincinnatiMiss Montgomery County
2018Matti-Lynn ChrismanCambridgeMiss Maple City
2017Sarah ClapperLouisvilleMiss Clayland
2016Alice MagotoCincinnatiMiss Portsmouth
2015Sarah HiderWoosterMiss Maple City
2014Mackenzie Bart (sf)ColumbusMiss Montgomery County
2013Heather WellsWarrenMiss Montgomery County
2012Elissa McCrackenAdaMiss West Central Ohio
2011Ellen Bryan (q)CelinaMiss Clayland
2010Becky MingerSylvaniaMiss All-American City
2009Erica GelhausSt. HenryMiss Clayland
2008Karissa MartinWoodsfieldMiss Clayland
2007Roberta CampGrove CityMiss Maple City
2006Melanie MurphyBrook ParkMiss Miami Valley
2005Marlia FontaineMassillonMiss Lake Erie
2004Amanda Beagle (t)WarrenMiss Lake Erie
2003Janelle CoutsAkronMiss Medina
2002Tiffany Haas (q)CincinnatiMiss Heart of it All
2001Natalie WitwerDublinMiss Ashland
2000Stephanie MeisbergerHopewellMiss North Coast
1999Tiffany BaumannClevelandMiss Greater Cleveland
1998Cheya WatkinsCincinnatiMiss Southeastern Ohio
1997Kelly CreagerHamlerMiss Conneaut
1996Robyn HancockGrand RapidsMiss Crestline
1995Ellen PasturzakPortsmouthMiss Portsmouth
1994Lea Mack (sf)PickeringtonMiss Pickerington-America
1993Titilayo Adedokun (2)CincinnatiMiss Americana
1992Robin Meade (sf)WakemanMiss Mansfield
1991Renee AuthersonNewarkMiss Central Ohio
1990Kristi CookeMarionMiss Willard
1989Kristin Huffman (4)Canal WinchesterMiss Pickerington-America
1988Sarah Ann EvansVan WertMiss Pickerington-America
1987Susan Kay JohnsonColumbusMiss Canton
1986Mary ZilbaToledoMiss Greater Toledo
1985Suellen Cochran (sf)HeathMiss Southeastern
1984Melissa Bradley (1)MansfieldMiss Clayland
1983Pamela Rigas (4)CanfieldMiss Cuyahoga Co. Fair
1982Debra GombertBexleyMiss North Central
1981Juliana ZilbaMansfieldMiss North Central
1980Kathy Vernon (sf)YoungstownMiss North Central
1979Tana Carli (1)LakewoodMiss Willard
1978Sher Patrick (sf)CentervilleMiss South Central
1977Joan GilgerMansfieldMiss Bowling Green
Susan   Perkins  (MA)MiddletownMiss Clayland
1976Janice CooleyPortsmouthMiss Ohio Valley
1975Susan Banks (3)RavennaMiss Warren
1974Lorrie KapstaColumbusMiss Franklin County
1973Cheryl YourkvitchLorainMiss Lorain
1972Karen SparkaBowling GreenMiss Bowling Green
1971Judy Jones Miss Miami University
Laurie   Lea Schaefer  (MA)BexleyMiss Bexley
1970Grace BirdAllianceMiss Alliance
1969Katherine Baumann (1)Bowling GreenMiss Bowling Green
1968Leslyn HipleLouisvilleMiss Canton
1967Pamela RobinsonDaytonMiss Dayton
1966Sharon Phillian (3)DelawareMiss Delaware
1965Valerie LavinCantonMiss Canton
1964Diane CourtwrightColumbusMiss Columbus
1963Peggy EmersonAkronMiss Akron
1962Bonne Gawronski Miss Toledo
Jacquelyn   Mayer  (MA)SanduskyMiss Vacationland
1961Darlene DepasqualeDaytonMiss Dayton
1960Alice McClainMarionMiss Marion
1959Carole WeilerCirclevilleMiss Circleville
1958Margaret PutmanAdaMiss Ada
1957Linda HattmanMansfieldMiss Mansfield
1956Roberta PalmerClevelandMiss Cleveland
1955Marguerite GarrCincinnatiMiss Cincinnati
1954Barbara Quinlin (sf)AllianceMiss Alliance
1953Martha ZimmermanSalemMiss Salem
1952Carol KoontzBolivarMiss Bolivar
1951Ruth HowellApple CreekMiss Apple Creek
1950Irene FarrenGrand RiverMiss Grand River
1949Florence BondiClevelandMiss Cleveland
1948Maxine WaackFairviewMiss Fairview
1947Nancy NesbittClevelandMiss Cleveland
1946LaVonne Bond (sf)Cincinnati 
Mary   Eileen KellyCleveland 
1945Julia DonahueOxford 
Virginia   Lee PleasantCincinnati 
1944Madeline BohanonCincinnati 
1943Joan HyldoftCincinnati 
1942Barbara PattersonCincinnati 
1941Janice Sulzman (sf)Willoughby 
Lois   Jean BeckCleveland 
1940Violet BerzeSteubenville 
Bette   Jane Hart  
1939Jeanne SabodaCleveland 
Maxine   Drumm  
1938Marilyn Meseke (MA)MarionMiss Marion
Evelyn Bertelsbeck (sf)Cleveland 
1937Jean Fadden (sf)Cleveland 
Evelyn   Townley (sf)  
Sally   Lillian FrankCincinnati 
1936Evelyn Townley (sf)  
Dorothy   A. DuncanCincinnati 
1935Beatrice PfeifferCincinnati 
Eleanore   PapinCleveland 
1933Corinne Porter (sf)  
1927Evelyn WilgusRussells Point 
1925Elarka TowneConneaut 
1924No Miss Ohio  
1923Mary Katherine Campbell  (MA)Columbus 
1922Mary Katherine Campbell (MA)Columbus 

(MA)  Miss America
(1) 1st Runner Up
(2) 2nd Runner Up
(3)  3rd Runner Up
(4) 4th Runner Up
(sf) Semifinalist
(q) Miss America Quality of Life Finalist
(t) Miss America Non Finalist Talent